Forums

Post Reply
Forum Home > Philosolhy Club > Gnosticism:Elitist, or Egalitarian?

Holder of the Secrets
Site Owner
Posts: 15

Gnosticism, as far as I have learned may bemore exclusivist than elitist, because it wasn’t until recently that itsMystical Sect’s books were available to the public (not to mention that thereare not many people on the path to enlightenment or wish to seek out themysteries of the universe!). I suggest that Gnosticism is more egalitarian thanelitist and I will outline two examples or parables from the Gospel of Thomasas an example of each and discuss why Gnosticism is more egalitarian thanelitist..

1. Gnosticism is egalitarian because…

Gospel of Thomas 64. Jesus said, "A person was receiving guests. Whenhe had prepared the dinner, he sent his slave to invite the guests.

The slave went to the first and said to that one, 'My master invites you.'That one said, 'Some merchants owe me money; they are coming to me tonight. Ihave to go and give them instructions. Please excuse me from dinner.'

The slave went to another and said to that one, 'My master has invited you.'That one said to the slave, 'I have bought a house, and I have been called awayfor a day. I shall have no time.'

The slave went to another and said to that one, 'My master invites you.'That one said to the slave, 'My friend is to be married, and I am to arrangethe banquet. I shall not be able to come. Please excuse me from dinner.'

The slave went to another and said to that one, 'My master invites you.'That one said to the slave, 'I have bought an estate, and I am going to collectthe rent. I shall not be able to come. Please excuse me.'

The slave returned and said to his master, 'Those whom you invited to dinner have asked to be excused.' The master said to his slave, 'Go out on the streetsand bring back whomever you find to have dinner.'

Buyers and merchants [will] not enter the places of my Father."  (from email of the Gospels).


Personal thoughts: This parable seems to me like the doorshave been open to those who wish to seek attendance at the unveiling of the mysteriesof the universe. (and they would thus gravitate” towards reunification with theOgdoad). Therefore, suggesting that pathways to God were (are) open to any who are willing (who are not buyers and merchants could mean those who revere material wealth over love/unification).

 

However, it could also be true, that thereis type of elitism involved, but it would only be applied to the title of theLamb or the one who claims to be Jesus or Horus in the Second Coming  

 

2. Gnosticism is elitist because…

 

(I07) Jesus said: The kingdom is like ashepherd who had hundred sheep. One of them, the biggest, went astray. He leftthe ninety-nine and sought after the one till he found it. When he hadlaboured, he said to the sheep: I love thee more than the ninety-nine.

 

Personal notes: So, perhaps there is a spotheld for One particular person, but there are many other sparks or “seats” tobe filled! One saved seat does not necessarily mean elitism!  There is reference to this sheep parable in adifferent way in a different Gospel in the Nag Hammadi collection. The Book ofBaruch by Justin [5] is followed by a list of angels who are also refered to as“trees” and  “The company of all theseangels together constitutes paradise… [6] The angels of paradise are called,allegorically, trees, and the tree of life is Baruch…” (Meyer, 2005 p. 269).What would happen if one of these trees was felled thus causing paradise todissolve? Much like the parable of the woman with the jar that broke and leakedout to realize there was nothing left in the jar when she arrived home in theGospel of Thomas? Could the parable of the cornerstone also fit here? Couldparadise be resurrected if that lost sheep or tree is found and returns home???Could Humpty Dumpty get put together again using this missing piece, or thislost sheep, big fish, and/or cornerstone? (See the Apocalypse section of http://www.thegrandpatchwork.com forelaboration).

 

Perhaps in order to put Paradiseback together again, we need all the pieces. This could be seen as the parableof the sparks at the beginning. The parable of the yeast leavening the wholeloaf (Thomas 96.) and resembles the story of Isis and Osiris as she gathered uphis pieces, which gives rise to the resurrection of Horus or Jesus as mentionedlast meeting). So, perhaps there are certain key spots that are reserved, butthe sparks are many. I could see how it could be considered elitist becausethere are certain pieces that come together, but it could also be seen thatthose pieces are those who search and are considered “perfect” or worthy. Theseseats are open to the public and the useless jars will be discarded (The Gospelof Truth by Valentinus’ Parable of the Broken Jars).

 


February 17, 2010 at 1:13 AM Flag Quote & Reply

Talis
Member
Posts: 20

your URL needs what to locate harddrive images ( then again use RG message board to reply, to avoid abuse)   I just lost the composed message, thanks to trying to remove embedded URL within this message ( re-direction, of course)..  This site does not retain context like RG , usual low level inattention. I keep telling myself dont work in little text boxes without saving to clipboard ,  to recall instructions is always difficult :

Look at the quantum pendulum problem , found here :

http://people.reed.edu/~crandall/papers/ja931424.pdf

test the cascades in 8.3 without recursion relations falling into the ground state, to see if  short -time expansion 8.16  fits , this may find the matrices we need to fill the coeff  tables by replacing derivatives with shift operators in 8.3  ( i think OK for 1pS x 1000 giving the real-time series across 1nS reiteration interval. )

Check for results on anharnmonic oscillator bound energy states  (sub- harmonic)just for  H+  (D2) with , and replacing H-muon excited state , to anharmonic series in muonic atom pairs, avoiding ground state (theory on ground-state is wrong, avoid Schrodinger indulgences) instead look for sub-harmonic resonance... 

check the abstract here, save + PDF : http://www.springerlink.com/content/m46g0825u82uq062/

i may find resonant relation texts , given more time .. above is improved on 1st

--

Study of Causes . Mind, does Matter. Mind eminates Causes.

July 10, 2011 at 7:47 PM Flag Quote & Reply

Talis
Member
Posts: 20

Long time no hear ...  a link to my current  site   http://Spiralshell.Co  tho reading the unified theories you propose, more than excites the future potential for this human race we find ourselves mixed into.  It is true both sides offer a piece to a  final approach to any problem, the facts are hard to find in this life of a lie that projects in wholesale portions, no matter what the state of economy.

The demise of America has been planned for quite some time , what exactly is best is hard to define without those forces acting upon the unwilling , even tho such outcomes are very predictable.  Apparently the power has shifted too far to the right, under the guise of stale improvements that remain empty promise , merely shifting attention to the voids in consciousness, of both proponents one blissfullllly aware of the disaster ahead, the other flapping its wings of flightless sentimentality , doom and endless argument that allows the right to wage war on such stupidity..

The rulers create a myth of power because they control legions of soldiers, even tho without soldiers they are powerless. So this puppet theatre remains , with politicians, military, police serving as protective layers to society which accepts this structure because it works today. The mythological layers of heaven formed much the same way. An ideal existance was broken by a smart-ass angel not happy with the politics of heaven, and took with him, bands of angels. The way heaven broke up, must have been known to God in advance, so the reality is He ordered this as a natural course of events, so as not to continue forever with the same lot of singing angels. I cant imagine a better way out - heaven turning into a mystery, leaving life in hell as the only way back to promised life. And then through a righteous spirit, which none deserve, there are so few to enter ANY kingdom, let alone heaven

Dont think so. The story of salvation is a promise for the stupid. Ask a monkey if it wants to live forever ,,, that biogenic masterpiece cant sing in tune , or keep its house in order. It kills its young if so provoked, as many within the animal species. Kingdoms are for dreamers. Go earn it without killing , and you can't , so the only instrument that makes mans day is manipulation of everything to suit his purpose.

Man easily imagines such devices, as a means to control growing population, a natural progression. This leaves God in the higher position, to diversify His creation. As nature destroys, it may be said that nature takes Its course in keeping Its mystery one step ahead ( out of reach ) and thus, keep things interesting.

One day , there will be intelligent reply.

 (((( ++ ))) ((( ))) ((( o n )))) = 11 ~ Thelema

--

Study of Causes . Mind, does Matter. Mind eminates Causes.

May 23, 2013 at 8:53 AM Flag Quote & Reply

Talis
Member
Posts: 20

One may think at least one physics genius has read this thread.. This test of time is human experience not idealism ..in thousands of folk i met one genius, an alcoholic with a olfactory issues threatening his future.. He wrote a hydrogen plasma collision simulator.. And theres Nobody else unafraid to surface to talk to this being.. Tsk ..Tsk.  human nature is a selfish one. Monkey shock. we begin to know some truth, beyond the brainwash.. it scares every genius, who rather perish silent then put a hand in.

This is a well researched  post by Holder of Secrets :  appears to support above opinion in a more drawn out production.. as u expecft in a thesis ..


WE all are racist ,as we cannot avoid Judgment of others .. All of us , even the prudish , silent in their Cave .. How on earth does agreement work?  By Force.

 

Organized Religion

 

Evangelical Christians are a group found to oppose racial equality (Devine, 2005) which could be described as Modern Racism. It has been found that the Protestant Work Ethic is correlated with anti-black attitudes (Katz & Hass, 1988). This makes sense because the Protestant Work Ethic is an ideology that promotes working hard and if you work hard you will get the things you deserve, ultimately entry into heaven. Thus, those who do not work hard are seen as lazy “parasites” and are not worthy of rewards from society. This is seen to create prejudice because if a group is labeled or assumed to be lazy, those who endorse the Protestant Work Ethic will deny privileges and harbour negative attitudes towards the group. Capitalism was a by-product of this Ethic because if you did business with someone, you would check their credentials with the church they were afiliated with (hunt, 2003). One would be true to their word that if you pay, they would deliver. If they didn't the church would ex-communicate you

Protestant work ethic .. allows parasites into their fold by such promise as equal opportunity . and anti discrirmination .. All great ideals just like communism .. but we dont have an ideal world, Nothing like it .. Samaritan laws allow corruption, as the "government" lets strangers into its fold, who lay bias in the workplace.  An example is Politics. which frustrates anyone trying to disclose fraud.

Australian radio, & theatre production.. prefers openly gay staff ..To a point that programs are filled with gay innuendo which assaults straight listeners.Prejudice with innuendo .. shop assistants start to influence employ of their own kind .. Chinese , are taking over postoffices ..everywhere .. an example of work network bias..even tho its preference due to opportuinity, its human bias.

Capitalism has inherited corruption dur to competitive motivation & profit.

There is no other influence.. it does not matter how it started, cal it an accident, the main thing is HOW it develops , it has done by all illegal advantage players had courage to throw .. Drugs started half the worlds hotel chains. The days of a family business growing up to starbucks size is only done thru birds of a feather investment .. Big money buying up the best real-estate to position dirty airconditioned comfort that seagulls flock to ..with their money. Happy birthD Helen for Sept

Organized Religion

 

Evangelical Christians are a group found to oppose racial equality (Devine, 2005) which could be described as Modern Racism. It has been found that the Protestant Work Ethic is correlated with anti-black attitudes (Katz & Hass, 1988). This makes sense because the Protestant Work Ethic is an ideology that promotes working hard and if you work hard you will get the things you deserve, ultimately entry into heaven. Thus, those who do not work hard are seen as lazy “parasites” and are not worthy of rewards from society. This is seen to create prejudice because if a group is labeled or assumed to be lazy, those who endorse the Protestant Work Ethic will deny privileges and harbour negative attitudes towards the group. Capitalism was a by-product of this Ethic because if you did business with someone, you would check their credentials with the church they were afiliated with (hunt, 2003). One would be true to their word that if you pay, they would deliver. If they didn't the church would ex-communicate you

 oney. So many ways to say this.. ITs after midnight, the shopping needs a home.. 



--

Study of Causes . Mind, does Matter. Mind eminates Causes.

November 21, 2015 at 9:00 AM Flag Quote & Reply

Talis
Member
Posts: 20

Really have to educate IT in this world, when u begin to edit prior to 10min then ALLOW the fresh upload . This still rejects an edit begun within 10 min. Ho Hum

November 21, 2015 at 9:18 AM Flagged Quote & Reply

Cochese
Member
Posts: 1

5 of cups

August 28, 2016 at 2:34 PM Flag Quote & Reply

Holder of the Secrets
Site Owner
Posts: 15

I see your 5 of Cups and respond with the Transmutation of the negative into Light.

August 31, 2016 at 9:57 PM Flag Quote & Reply

Holder of the Secrets
Site Owner
Posts: 15

Talis at November 21, 2015 at 9:18 AM

Really have to educate IT in this world, when u begin to edit prior to 10min then ALLOW the fresh upload . This still rejects an edit begun within 10 min. Ho Hum

hummm. I wish I was in control of that part of it or knew how to program it so it allows that. It is just another way to control and supress our voice. The media has taken over the message. Error 404

December 9, 2016 at 12:23 AM Flag Quote & Reply

Holder of the Secrets
Site Owner
Posts: 15

Holder of the Secrets at February 17, 2010 at 1:13 AM

Gnosticism, as far as I have learned may bemore exclusivist than elitist, because it wasn’t until recently that itsMystical Sect’s books were available to the public (not to mention that thereare not many people on the path to enlightenment or wish to seek out themysteries of the universe!). I suggest that Gnosticism is more egalitarian thanelitist and I will outline two examples or parables from the Gospel of Thomasas an example of each and discuss why Gnosticism is more egalitarian thanelitist..

1. Gnosticism is egalitarian because…

Gospel of Thomas 64. Jesus said, "A person was receiving guests. Whenhe had prepared the dinner, he sent his slave to invite the guests.

The slave went to the first and said to that one, 'My master invites you.'That one said, 'Some merchants owe me money; they are coming to me tonight. Ihave to go and give them instructions. Please excuse me from dinner.'

The slave went to another and said to that one, 'My master has invited you.'That one said to the slave, 'I have bought a house, and I have been called awayfor a day. I shall have no time.'

The slave went to another and said to that one, 'My master invites you.'That one said to the slave, 'My friend is to be married, and I am to arrangethe banquet. I shall not be able to come. Please excuse me from dinner.'

The slave went to another and said to that one, 'My master invites you.'That one said to the slave, 'I have bought an estate, and I am going to collectthe rent. I shall not be able to come. Please excuse me.'

The slave returned and said to his master, 'Those whom you invited to dinner have asked to be excused.' The master said to his slave, 'Go out on the streetsand bring back whomever you find to have dinner.'

Buyers and merchants [will] not enter the places of my Father."  (from email of the Gospels).


Personal thoughts: This parable seems to me like the doorshave been open to those who wish to seek attendance at the unveiling of the mysteriesof the universe. (and they would thus gravitate” towards reunification with theOgdoad). Therefore, suggesting that pathways to God were (are) open to any who are willing (who are not buyers and merchants could mean those who revere material wealth over love/unification).

 

However, it could also be true, that thereis type of elitism involved, but it would only be applied to the title of theLamb or the one who claims to be Jesus or Horus in the Second Coming  

 

2. Gnosticism is elitist because…

 

(I07) Jesus said: The kingdom is like ashepherd who had hundred sheep. One of them, the biggest, went astray. He leftthe ninety-nine and sought after the one till he found it. When he hadlaboured, he said to the sheep: I love thee more than the ninety-nine.

 

Personal notes: So, perhaps there is a spotheld for One particular person, but there are many other sparks or “seats” tobe filled! One saved seat does not necessarily mean elitism!  There is reference to this sheep parable in adifferent way in a different Gospel in the Nag Hammadi collection. The Book ofBaruch by Justin [5] is followed by a list of angels who are also refered to as“trees” and  “The company of all theseangels together constitutes paradise… [6] The angels of paradise are called,allegorically, trees, and the tree of life is Baruch…” (Meyer, 2005 p. 269).What would happen if one of these trees was felled thus causing paradise todissolve? Much like the parable of the woman with the jar that broke and leakedout to realize there was nothing left in the jar when she arrived home in theGospel of Thomas? Could the parable of the cornerstone also fit here? Couldparadise be resurrected if that lost sheep or tree is found and returns home???Could Humpty Dumpty get put together again using this missing piece, or thislost sheep, big fish, and/or cornerstone? (See the Apocalypse section of http://www.thegrandpatchwork.com forelaboration).

 

Perhaps in order to put Paradiseback together again, we need all the pieces. This could be seen as the parableof the sparks at the beginning. The parable of the yeast leavening the wholeloaf (Thomas 96.) and resembles the story of Isis and Osiris as she gathered uphis pieces, which gives rise to the resurrection of Horus or Jesus as mentionedlast meeting). So, perhaps there are certain key spots that are reserved, butthe sparks are many. I could see how it could be considered elitist becausethere are certain pieces that come together, but it could also be seen thatthose pieces are those who search and are considered “perfect” or worthy. Theseseats are open to the public and the useless jars will be discarded (The Gospelof Truth by Valentinus’ Parable of the Broken Jars).

 


It appears as though the 'so called update' that transferred my site was a ruse

December 9, 2016 at 12:26 AM Flag Quote & Reply

Holder of the Secrets
Site Owner
Posts: 15

Talis at May 23, 2013 at 8:53 AM

Long time no hear ...  a link to my current  site   http://Spiralshell.Co  tho reading the unified theories you propose, more than excites the future potential for this human race we find ourselves mixed into.  It is true both sides offer a piece to a  final approach to any problem, the facts are hard to find in this life of a lie that projects in wholesale portions, no matter what the state of economy.

The demise of America has been planned for quite some time , what exactly is best is hard to define without those forces acting upon the unwilling , even tho such outcomes are very predictable.  Apparently the power has shifted too far to the right, under the guise of stale improvements that remain empty promise , merely shifting attention to the voids in consciousness, of both proponents one blissfullllly aware of the disaster ahead, the other flapping its wings of flightless sentimentality , doom and endless argument that allows the right to wage war on such stupidity..

The rulers create a myth of power because they control legions of soldiers, even tho without soldiers they are powerless. So this puppet theatre remains , with politicians, military, police serving as protective layers to society which accepts this structure because it works today. The mythological layers of heaven formed much the same way. An ideal existance was broken by a smart-ass angel not happy with the politics of heaven, and took with him, bands of angels. The way heaven broke up, must have been known to God in advance, so the reality is He ordered this as a natural course of events, so as not to continue forever with the same lot of singing angels. I cant imagine a better way out - heaven turning into a mystery, leaving life in hell as the only way back to promised life. And then through a righteous spirit, which none deserve, there are so few to enter ANY kingdom, let alone heaven

Dont think so. The story of salvation is a promise for the stupid. Ask a monkey if it wants to live forever ,,, that biogenic masterpiece cant sing in tune , or keep its house in order. It kills its young if so provoked, as many within the animal species. Kingdoms are for dreamers. Go earn it without killing , and you can't , so the only instrument that makes mans day is manipulation of everything to suit his purpose.

Man easily imagines such devices, as a means to control growing population, a natural progression. This leaves God in the higher position, to diversify His creation. As nature destroys, it may be said that nature takes Its course in keeping Its mystery one step ahead ( out of reach ) and thus, keep things interesting.

One day , there will be intelligent reply.

 (((( ++ ))) ((( ))) ((( o n )))) = 11 ~ Thelema

I think this is the first post of yours that actually went through and wasn't broken lines of thought. Thank you for the moment of clarity and I have to admit I agree with a lot you are saying. The links still don't work, but I will try to keep searching. It is not that nature keeps one step ahead, it's that 'man' detatches and pushes itself away from God then blames God for it. God stayes the same luminescent ball in the 'sky' -it is our perpective that changes.  We obsure ourselves from it. Nature is the mirror representation of this.

December 9, 2016 at 12:37 AM Flag Quote & Reply

Holder of the Secrets
Site Owner
Posts: 15

Talis at November 21, 2015 at 9:00 AM

One may think at least one physics genius has read this thread.. This test of time is human experience not idealism ..in thousands of folk i met one genius, an alcoholic with a olfactory issues threatening his future.. He wrote a hydrogen plasma collision simulator.. And theres Nobody else unafraid to surface to talk to this being.. Tsk ..Tsk.  human nature is a selfish one. Monkey shock. we begin to know some truth, beyond the brainwash.. it scares every genius, who rather perish silent then put a hand in.

This is a well researched  post by Holder of Secrets :  appears to support above opinion in a more drawn out production.. as u expecft in a thesis ..


WE all are racist ,as we cannot avoid Judgment of others .. All of us , even the prudish , silent in their Cave .. How on earth does agreement work?  By Force.

 

Organized Religion

 

Evangelical Christians are a group found to oppose racial equality (Devine, 2005) which could be described as Modern Racism. It has been found that the Protestant Work Ethic is correlated with anti-black attitudes (Katz & Hass, 1988). This makes sense because the Protestant Work Ethic is an ideology that promotes working hard and if you work hard you will get the things you deserve, ultimately entry into heaven. Thus, those who do not work hard are seen as lazy “parasites” and are not worthy of rewards from society. This is seen to create prejudice because if a group is labeled or assumed to be lazy, those who endorse the Protestant Work Ethic will deny privileges and harbour negative attitudes towards the group. Capitalism was a by-product of this Ethic because if you did business with someone, you would check their credentials with the church they were afiliated with (hunt, 2003). One would be true to their word that if you pay, they would deliver. If they didn't the church would ex-communicate you

Protestant work ethic .. allows parasites into their fold by such promise as equal opportunity . and anti discrirmination .. All great ideals just like communism .. but we dont have an ideal world, Nothing like it .. Samaritan laws allow corruption, as the "government" lets strangers into its fold, who lay bias in the workplace.  An example is Politics. which frustrates anyone trying to disclose fraud.

Australian radio, & theatre production.. prefers openly gay staff ..To a point that programs are filled with gay innuendo which assaults straight listeners.Prejudice with innuendo .. shop assistants start to influence employ of their own kind .. Chinese , are taking over postoffices ..everywhere .. an example of work network bias..even tho its preference due to opportuinity, its human bias.

Capitalism has inherited corruption dur to competitive motivation & profit.

There is no other influence.. it does not matter how it started, cal it an accident, the main thing is HOW it develops , it has done by all illegal advantage players had courage to throw .. Drugs started half the worlds hotel chains. The days of a family business growing up to starbucks size is only done thru birds of a feather investment .. Big money buying up the best real-estate to position dirty airconditioned comfort that seagulls flock to ..with their money. Happy birthD Helen for Sept

Organized Religion

 

Evangelical Christians are a group found to oppose racial equality (Devine, 2005) which could be described as Modern Racism. It has been found that the Protestant Work Ethic is correlated with anti-black attitudes (Katz & Hass, 1988). This makes sense because the Protestant Work Ethic is an ideology that promotes working hard and if you work hard you will get the things you deserve, ultimately entry into heaven. Thus, those who do not work hard are seen as lazy “parasites” and are not worthy of rewards from society. This is seen to create prejudice because if a group is labeled or assumed to be lazy, those who endorse the Protestant Work Ethic will deny privileges and harbour negative attitudes towards the group. Capitalism was a by-product of this Ethic because if you did business with someone, you would check their credentials with the church they were afiliated with (hunt, 2003). One would be true to their word that if you pay, they would deliver. If they didn't the church would ex-communicate you

 oney. So many ways to say this.. ITs after midnight, the shopping needs a home.. 



I don't know why I have to quote and reply - and I can't delete the repetition of the above quote [plus I'm not sure where my replies are going, but here are my thoughts lol. Yes, perhaps it doesn't matter HOW it develops - that would save me a long drawn out thesis! ;) thanks for that! but develops is the key word that causes the problems. The definition of development is the problem. Neoliberal definitions of development are the cause of the problem. So called advancements in the name of 'development' are destructive and destroy 3rd world resources and land, scratch that- it's come full circle and ended up back here too. We are duped into thinking that development is good, but it is use as an excuse to exploit.  I would suggest a reconstruction of the definition of development - one that is more inclusive and utiizes talents and togetherness, rather than destruction, selfishness and greed. Those are things of the past.


And just because someone prefers not to be selfish, it doesn't mean that they're a communist - sheesh. Free yourself from ignorance!!! BALANCE THE TALENTS!!! 

December 9, 2016 at 12:47 AM Flag Quote & Reply

You must login to post.